The long and short of it is that it's not safe.
The problem starts when, say, I have USDT to sell and someone wants to pay me in Turkish lira. I make a deal on Binance P2P. For the sake of argument, let's call the buyer Peter Murat. Peter Murat wants to buy my 1,000 USDT, and he's going to pay 50,000 lira into my account.
The thing is, Binance P2P tells me that the money must come from Peter Murat's own account. If Peter Murat says he's going to pay from any other account, I should refuse. But if I refuse, in most cases he blocks me and usually holds the trade open until the escrow time runs out. That could be 30, 60, 90 or 180 minutes, but either way the deal is lost.
Why? Because he doesn't want to deal with me. He doesn't want to deal with anyone who insists on being paid directly from Peter Murat's account.
So I try another one. I find someone else, Susan. Same thing with Susan. I ask, "Susan, are you going to pay me from your own account?" She says no. Again, either she blocks me, or she doesn't block me and my USDT is stuck in escrow. This is what happens.
What happens if you go along with Peter Murat and say, "Okay, fine, I'll accept money from some other account"? You then find that someone called, say, Kutlu has sent you the money. You receive the 50,000 lira and it's all done.
A couple of weeks or months later, the police may come and ask you:
"Do you know Kutlu?"
You don't, because Kutlu was a partner of Peter Murat.
"Then why did he send you money?"
"He didn't send me money. I did a deal with Peter Murat."
"Did Peter Murat send you money from his account?"
"No. He said he'd send it through another account."
"Do you have the details of this person: telephone number, name, address, city?"
No, you don't have anything. "So why would Peter Murat have someone else pay you?"
You keep saying, "Peter Murat said he'd send the money through a friend, Kutlu was that friend, and he sent it." Then it turns out that Kutlu was involved in a fraud with someone else, who was involved with someone else, and so on.
Say there's a man called Alan. Alan was defrauded by someone, and out of all the accounts Alan paid money into, Kutlu's was one of them. Then Kutlu sent that money to me.
Naturally, the prosecutors or the police will assume I had something to do with it, and this can get your bank accounts blocked. This type of P2P fraud is common on Binance, and Binance doesn't stop it. Binance has covered itself by saying, "If you accept a payment that comes from anyone else, we are not responsible. You must only accept payment from the buyer's own account."
The problem is that none of the P2P traders online who are willing to trade will pay from their own account. None of them. If that rule can't be enforced, people start to think it's normal in the industry to accept payments from a third party, and then they get burned.
So how should it work? It's Binance's responsibility to make sure that the seller has a way to block, report, or properly flag this person: "This person is sending me money from here and there, and I have no idea where they are." Peter Murat could be operating from Romania, from Iran, from Iraq, or anywhere else. I have no idea where he actually is. All I know is that he has got hold of some people in Turkey with bank accounts who are willing to transfer money to me.
Once that transaction is done, the chances are very high that I will get into trouble. Then I have to go and defend myself and prove that this was a genuine deal and that I did not defraud anyone.
So, to the question you're asking, "Is Binance P2P safe?": No, it's not safe. It comes with its own consequences.